Cultivator vs. Tiller – What’s the Difference & When to Use Which?

Taking good care of your garden often includes various equipment. If you are just starting, you might be thinking about buying a cultivator or a tiller.

While they might look very similar, these are two completely different machines. Keep reading to find out more about cultivator vs. tiller, and which piece of equipment might fit your needs better.


Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you shop through the links on YardThyme, we may earn an affiliate's commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. For more information, read full disclosure here.

Cultivator vs Tiller: What’s The Real Difference?

Gardening requires a lot of work and patience. Beginners might not know the difference between a cultivator and a tiller, and that is perfectly fine. After all, both of these machines are designed to improve the quality of the soil.

However, a tiller is great for breaking down the hard ground and digging, while cultivators are perfect for mixing up the soil in your garden and making it healthier.

Continue reading for a more in-depth comparison of the tiller vs. cultivator so you can better determine which machine you need.

Tillers – A Closer Look

Tillers are incredibly sturdy and designed to dig deep into the ground (see this article for some of the best tillers for breaking in new ground).

These machines will be incredibly useful if you want to maintain your garden and break the hard soil. While there are three types of tillers out there, the majority of users choose either a front-tine tiller or rear-tine tiller.

Mid-tine tillers are not so common among gardening enthusiasts. They need gasoline to work. Choosing the right tiller depends on how deep you need to dig, as well as the size of your yard.

Front-tine tillers

Front-tine tillers are suitable for gardens that are on the smaller side. The tines are placed in the front of the machine, making it easier to maneuver over the surface.

They are great for not too hard ground and mixing the soil. If you have a lot of shrubbery and flowerbeds in your garden, a front-tine tiller will not cut the plant roots.

You will have complete control over the movement because the wheels are located in the back, so using it in a small garden will be easy.

Rear-tine tillers

Rear-tine tillers are bigger and more powerful due to the overall weight of the machine. They are designed for bigger gardens with rocky or hard soil. These machines are not commonly used in small yards.

If you have a large plot of land with soil that is difficult to break, getting a rototiller could be a great idea. When we compare a rototiller vs. cultivator, it is clear that the gasoline-powered machine will deliver better results and loosen up hard soil without a problem.

Cultivators – A Closer Look

Cultivators are smaller than tillers and made for garden maintenance. They are not as powerful as tillers. Instead, cultivators prepare the soil for planting, as well as mix the compost and fertilizer.

These machines can be used for weed control during the season as they can cut weeds. Cultivators are an excellent investment because they can help your garden thrive. They are user-friendly and easy to store.

So if you have a small or medium-sized garden, cultivators could help you bring your gardening game to a whole new level. Choosing the right cultivator mostly depends on the power source you wish to use.

Mini cultivator

When you hear the word cultivator, you probably picture the humongous machines slowly moving over the fields. That is certainly not the case here. But when we compare disc cultivator vs. tiller, they still have two completely different functions.

A mini cultivator is like a shrunken version of a large cultivator, and it is a superb piece of equipment for your yard. They have up to three tines in the front and work tirelessly to mix up the soil.

As previously mentioned, the preferred power source will help you determine which cultivator you need. For instance, a mini cultivator usually runs on gas. If you have a medium-sized yard and don’t mind filling up the tank now and then, this is the right cultivator for you.

Electric cultivator

On the other hand, electric cultivators run on electricity. All you need to do is plug it into the socket, and that’s it.

Keep in mind that electric cultivators are not cordless, so they are recommended for smaller gardens. They are as powerful as a mini cultivator, so you will still get the same results. The only difference is that you need to deal with a cord.

The handy design of these machines could help you out with aerating the soil and making your garden ready for planting.

Cultivator vs. Tiller: Which One Should You Choose?

two lands divided by a road


After listing all the details about cultivators and tillers, now is the right time to decide which machine you need for your garden.

To quickly recap, a tiller is used for breaking new ground, while a cultivator mixes the already broken ground with fertilizer and compost.

Tillers are undoubtedly more powerful and can go deeper into the soil.

Cultivators are designed to cultivate the ground and make it suitable for planting.

Tillers are perfect for larger garden plots, but they are certainly bulkier than mini cultivators. Therefore, you need to have more storage space for these machines. Their engines require a lot of gas, but tillers can complete the job in less time when compared to cultivators.

When we put a tractor cultivator vs. tiller, the tiller is still better for a medium-sized garden. Bigger machines are just more suitable for vast plots of land. So if you are dealing with a hard soil in your yard, a tiller could solve this problem.

Cultivators are lighter, more compact, and suitable for small gardens. This piece of equipment could help you a lot when it comes to yard maintenance. Unfortunately, they are not as efficient as tillers when it comes to breaking new ground. You can try, but cultivators can’t go that deep.

A cultivator will help you prepare the soil for retaining moisture, mix in the compost, remove the weeds, and even aerate the yard.


It is difficult to choose between a cultivator and a tiller. Owning both machines is ideal, but if you need to select one, a cultivator might be a better choice, especially if the ground in your yard is already loosened.

You will be using a cultivator more often throughout the year. It is a versatile device that will come in handy for garden maintenance, especially if you don’t need to break up the ground in your yard.

Andy Gibson

My name's Gibson. Andy Gibson. I like to think of myself as the Bond of the backyard, that is if yard work ever became sexy. I write about everything about indoor and outdoor gardening and the dread-it-but-still-need-to-do-it chores around the yard, like cleaning out the gutter guards.

Recent Content